Eliza Carthy has had the impossible thrust upon her very early in life. With parents from the musical nobility of England, and with an awful lot of awards and accolades to her credit, she is inevitably faced with keeping stride, producing at a pitch few young performers can deal with. So far she's done well, and with Red Rice continues her trek towards perfection, with inevitable stumbles and some fine achievements. Red Rice is an ambitious two CD project, each focusing on a distinct yet related style. Red is the "contemporary" album. Her band uses reggae, folk, 60s and 70s folk-rock and 90s rave to mix it up on original and traditional tunes. Much of it harkens back to Steeleye Span and Fairport, good fun, but nothing earth shattering. The tracks that really win your heart are the ones that pull themselves out of the tradition, like the barrelhouse boogie of "Stumbling On" (penned by mom Norma Waterson) and Carthy's own "Russia (Call Waiting)," which presses a lot of buttons (electronically and figuratively) and succeeds wonderfully.
On Rice we get the folkier side. Which is not to say less adventurous, just more rooted. With Saul Rose on accordions, the cryptic "Fontenots" on guitar and vocals, Ed Boyd on guitar and Eleanor Waterson and Lucy Adams on vocals she gets to really show off her great musicianship and skill as an arranger; lots of energy, lots of attitude. Just listen to "Zycanthos Jig." Grace, skill and perception abound. Carthy is carving herself a niche in the musical life, and Red Rice is further proof that she has the guts to try, fail and often succeed. - CF